The Becoming Letters · November · Week One

What gratitude looked like for me the year I had nothing figured out

I was grateful. I was grieving. And the voice in my head had opinions about both.

Story5 Min ReadTuesday, November 3, 2026

A little over a year ago, I made a decision I couldn't fully explain to anyone, including myself.

I was going to move home. Miami back to Colorado. I didn't know if I'd still have a job when I got there. I didn't have a tidy plan. I just knew, in the part of me that doesn't argue, that I needed to go home.

So I went.

And here's the part that still makes me shake my head: it worked out. Almost all of it. I drove the whole way myself, four days from Miami to Denver, just me and the road. It turned out to be one of the most beautiful trips of my life. I found a townhome that felt like it had been waiting for me, twenty-five minutes from my youngest son at the university. And I got to keep my job.

If you'd told me all of that the night I decided to leave, I wouldn't have believed you. I was so thankful.

And then the other voice showed up.

What felt fake

It didn't sound cruel at first. It sounded reasonable. It even sounded like gratitude.

"You should be thankful. If you hadn't decided to try to love again, if you hadn't gotten married, you wouldn't have had to make any of these decisions. You'd still be in Colorado. So yes. You should be thankful."

Read that again and notice what it's doing. It uses the word thankful, but it isn't gratitude. It's a verdict. It takes every good thing that happened and turns it into evidence against me. Look how much you had to fix. Look what your choices cost.

That was the gratitude that felt fake. Not because the blessings weren't real. They were. It felt fake because I was using thankfulness to shut down everything else I felt. Every time the grief rose up, for the marriage, for the hope I'd walked into it with, for the version of me who believed it would be different, I'd stack a "but you should be grateful" right on top of it. And the self-criticism rode in right behind.

So that year wasn't just gratitude. It was gratitude, grief, and self-criticism, all tangled together. And I kept trying to make the first one cancel out the other two.

It never worked.

What felt real

The gratitude that felt real was small and specific, and it didn't come with a lecture attached.

None of those asked me to deny anything. I could be grateful for that drive and still grieve what made it necessary. I could love that townhome and still miss the life I thought I'd be living. Those weren't contradictions. They were both just true.

What eventually shifted

Nothing shifted overnight. What shifted was that I stayed the course.

I stayed when the grief was heavy. I stayed when the self-criticism was loud. And I went back to the things I've always known keep me well: my yoga practice, therapy, the daily habits I'd let slip, and the self-love I had somehow decided I needed to earn back.

Slowly, the voice lost its grip. Not because I argued it into silence, but because I stopped letting gratitude be a weapon. I let myself say: I'm grateful I came home, and I'm grieving what it took to get here. Both sentences got to stay.

Now here I sit, one year later, on the other side of that decision. I'm coming back to myself. Not the woman I was before Miami. Someone steadier. Someone who knows she can walk through a year with nothing figured out and still find her way home.

Gratitude was never supposed to silence my grief. It was supposed to hold me up while I felt it.

If you're in your own year of nothing figured out, here's what I want you to know. You don't have to earn your gratitude by pretending you're fine. And you don't have to prove you're ungrateful before you're allowed to grieve. You get both.

Try This Week

Catch one "you should be thankful."

The next time you hear yourself say "I should be grateful," pause and ask: what is this "should" trying to cover up?

Then rewrite it with one small word: "I'm grateful for ___, and I'm still grieving ___." Say it out loud once. Notice what loosens.

Next week, I'll walk you through the full Both/And practice, step by step, so you have it in your pocket before the holidays arrive.

— Monique

With you in the becoming · Verisage & Co.

Free November Guide

Both Things at Once

A guide to holding gratitude and grief at the same time, with the Both/And journaling practice and honest tools for the holiday table.

Get the free guide